HARTFORD, Conn. (AP) — The Connecticut Supreme Court on Monday overturned the death sentence of a man convicted in a murder-for-hire plot that promised him a broken snowmobile, saying the trial judge wrongly withheld key evidence from the jury.
Justices ordered a new penalty phase in the case of former Torrington resident Eduardo Santiago, 32, who was one of three men convicted in the fatal shooting of 45-year-old Joseph Niwinski in West Hartford in 2000. The other defendants pleaded guilty and are serving life in prison.
The court, however, upheld Santiago's conviction . A new penalty phase hasn't been scheduled yet.
The Supreme Court said the trial judge, Elliot Solomon, failed to disclose "significant and relevant" mitigating evidence against the death penalty during the trial. Justices said Solomon released only limited portions of a confidential file kept by the state Department of Children and Families that detailed Santiago's troubled childhood, which included beatings and sexual molestation.
"Although the trial court properly protected the defendant's due process rights under the fourteenth amendment to the United States constitution when it reviewed the department's file ... the scope of that court's review nevertheless failed to disclose potentially mitigating evidence relevant under the eighth amendment, thus requiring that the defendant receive a new penalty phase hearing," Justice Flemming L. Norcott Jr. wrote in the ruling.
All seven members of the court were in favor of overturning the death sentence, but Justice Lubbie Harper Jr. wrote in a concurring opinion that he believed the death penalty is unconstitutional and that Santiago should be resentenced to life in prison without the possibility of release.
In Connecticut, juries that convict defendants of capital felony must then consider whether to recommend the death penalty or life in prison without the possibility of release by deciding whether proven aggravating factors outweigh proven mitigating factors.
Prosecutors said Santiago agreed to kill Niwinski in exchange for a pink-striped snowmobile with a broken clutch in 2000, claims that Santiago denied. Santiago was sentenced to lethal injection in 2005 after a jury convicted him, despite no clear evidence that he was the one who pulled the rifle trigger.
Prosecutors say the plot to kill Niwinski was hatched by Mark Pascual, who owned a shop in Torrington that sold snowmobiles, boats and ATVs. Authorities say Pascual was infatuated with Niwinski's girlfriend, believed Niwinski was abusing her and her children and wanted him dead.
Santiago and a friend, Matthew Tyrell, admitted going into Niwinski's home the night of the murder, but both men claimed the other was the shooter.
Santiago's lawyer, Assistant Public Defender Mark Rademacher, didn't immediately return a message Monday. The prosecutor in the appeal, Marjorie Allen Dauster, said she couldn't immediately comment because she was reviewing the ruling.
Copyright 2013 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
GREENWICH, Conn. (AP) — A multi-vehicle crash closed part of Interstate 95 in southwestern Connecticut for about two hours as road conditions turned slippery with the arrival of a wintry storm.
Lawmakers in Connecticut and New York are calling on the Federal Railroad Administration to take immediate action to try and prevent another deadly train crash like the one that happened last weekend in New York City.
Members of the Machinists union who work at jet-engine maker Pratt & Whitney have approved a new three-year contract.
Manchester police are investigating what lead one man to allegedly kill three women and then take his own life.
The University of Connecticut has awarded the first two scholarships under a program launched to help those affected by last year's massacre at the Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown.
A student accused of setting off a lockdown and massive police response at Central Connecticut State University by wearing a ninja-like costume on campus is set to face a judge for the first time.
Newtown police officers rescued two people from a house fire, early Sunday.
Enfield resident Harold Slater was just 20-years-old the day he witnessed the bombing of Pearl Harbor.
Two men were arrested after breaking into a home then driving at officers during a pursuit in Waterbury on Saturday night.
HARTFORD, Conn. (AP) — Connecticut's governor is calling for houses of worship to mark the first anniversary of the Newtown school shooting by ringing their bells 26 times — once for each of the victims killed inside Sandy Hook Elementary …